The Right Time To Ask For More

Posted on 01/02/2018 - by Dan Allenby

In the world of fundraising, giving patterns vary widely. Every donor gives in a manner and at times that are uniquely right for them. In the case of most educational institutions, the majority of alumni won’t even make a single gift during their lifetime. Fewer still will ever make a major or planned gift. Even so, recognizing common giving patterns for those who do give can help you, as a fundraiser, plan solicitations that will (hopefully) steadily increase a donor’s giving over time.

Consider the lifelong pattern of an ideal alumni donor, which might look something like this:

  • Before graduation, they make their first gift through the senior class gift campaign
  • 1-15 years out, they make consistent donations to the annual fund
  • 15-30 years out, they make leadership gifts to the annual fund
  • 30+ years out, they make a major gift or planned gift

These stages suggest a model for cultivating alumni in a way that’s most likely to be in line with their own circumstances and capacity. For example, it’s probably not realistic to expect a recent graduate to be able to make a major gift since they are just starting out in their careers and in accumulating assets. Nor is it realistic to expect someone who has never donated before to make a major or planned gift if your institution has done nothing to build a relationship with them over time.

Encouraging people to move through these various stages of giving is often referred to as building a pipeline, and it’s one of the most important functions of an annual giving program. It begins with identifying and acquiring new donors, encouraging their consistent support, and raising their sights in a way that leads to their increased giving over time. A strong pipeline will ultimately produce a pool of prospects that have been regularly solicited, appropriately stewarded, and prepared for a conversation about a major or planned gift.

Make no mistake: every donor is unique with his or her own motives and interests. Cultivating relationships with donors based on their individual characteristics – and timing your solicitations accordingly – is fundamental and essential for successful fundraising. But it’s also important to be able to step back and see individual donors within a bigger context. Doing so can not only help you determine when it’s an appropriate time to ask for a gift, but it can also help you gauge when it’s the right time to go back and ask for more.

Want to learn more? CLICK HERE for AGN’s Webinar on Upgrading Donors to Higher Giving Levels.